Sunday, December 04, 2011

From The Papers: An Amateur's Reactions To Other Amateurs' Reactions; Or, Trawling The Letters Page

I've often wondered about the sort of people who write letters to the editor, myself being one of them from time to time. There is a spectrum, of course, from liberal to conservative, articulate to incoherent, thoughtful to screeching. In today's Santa Cruz Sentinel, however, the four letters seem to come from the same cross-section of humanity, all with the same target, the Occupy Santa Cruz movement.

The letters range from the irritated to the outright hostile, bordering on sanctimonious. As with many letters to the editor, I think every individual letter speaks more to the individual writer than the issue being addressed. These letters feel somewhat selfish, like each person, rather than addressing a solution for the larger issues raised by the Occupy Santa Cruz movement, is simply trying to vent their own visceral reactions and collect their 15 minutes of fame.

My harvesting of their letters as fodder for this blog is in no way the same thing. I mean it.

So the Occupy movement is certainly a controversial one. In the main, I sympathize with the causes associated therein, such as reforming Wall Street and the banking/lending processes that put so many people in bad situations, and the need to re-examine our economic practices that create such disparity in terms of wealth in this country. Such an examination should, of course, be taken from the microscopic--so to speak--to the macroscopic to view how the US operates in the global economy. There are, however, a few problems that have emerged during the Occupy phenomenon, which have distorted the message and allowed critics traction. For instance, there have been issues with violence and anarchy attaching themselves to what should be a peaceful assembly. And in Santa Cruz, for example, there is controversy over the fact that some individuals, ostensibly independent of but in sympathy with Occupy Santa Cruz, took over an empty building that used to house a bank.

Let's look at the letters, for a snapshot of how some local people view the movement. I'll summarize and offer my thoughts on each letter. Bear in mind, these are my subjective responses to the letters.

One gentleman suggests that protesters go to the residence of the person they have a problem with and block their street and mess up their area, and not the parks. First of all, I'm not sure if the person is serious or not, but there is no one residence, and no one person for the protesters to focus on. They are protesting an overarching issue in society, which requires a public venue for their right to assemble and express their feelings. Here we run into the question of public property, and whether an Occupy movement is impinging on the rights of others to use that public property by staying there for an extended period. That is always a grey area, and I don't have an answer, but I would tend to argue for the rights of people to peacefully assemble in a public area without restriction, until health and safety issues develop. The trouble is, the longer they stay there, the more likely issues are likely to occur, from homeless merging with the campers, to the natural flaring of tempers and other conflict. My perception of Occupy Santa Cruz is that it has been fairly well managed and controlled, both by the protesters and the city.

The gentleman also makes another claim that just makes no sense to me. He says the college students at UCSC who occupied a building on campus should not pay tuition and not attend any classes for 90 days. I don't understand his point on this one, saying that would accomplish something other than chaos. If they protest the higher tuition rates, certainly not paying is one option, although in the present system, higher education does require resources, and students should pay for their fair share if they are going to partake of those resources. But my understanding of the UCSC protest was that it related more to the pepper-spraying at UC Davis than anything else. This confusion perhaps speaks to the somewhat unfocused nature of the protest; or maybe it argues against the presence of a single movement, but rather many separate, related but independent protests.

Another letter writer complains about a photo of the UCSC police chief interacting in a jovial fashion. Apparently the letter writer would prefer the police take a hardline with student occupiers. Apparently the letter writer considers an act of civil disobedience to be an unforgivable crime. Never mind that the building being occupied was a university building, and therefore public, funded by the public and by tuition. Do the students have a legitimate right to block entry to a building, to deny workers entry? Maybe or maybe not, but it would not be as black and white an issue as this letter-writer suggests. It is a sensitive issue, especially in light of the outrageous pepper-spraying at UC Davis, so I say that any effort to find a harmonious resolution between the police and the protesters is to be commended.

Another writer sneeringly advised the "Occupiers" to walk around the Earth in five years, to broaden their focus and "'Occupy' a progressive place, the next turf you step to as you travel." First of all, you can't walk around the Earth. There are all these vast bodies of water that get in the way. You might have heard of them. There's one right next door. Second, I find it interesting that he says they should go to a progressive place, as if Santa Cruz were not progressive. I haven't lived here long enough to form a conclusion, but my impression has always been that it is progressive, as measured by the number of men who feel free to play the bongos while overlooking the ocean.

The point that really raised my eyebrows and hackles about this letter, though, was that the man said the Occupiers should realize that search for "fairness" is childish, because it doesn't exist, 'never has, never will.' He seems to imply that means that we shouldn't make an effort to make things more fair. That seems the more childish attitude to me, either from someone who has benefited from unfair actions, or by someone who is so insecure and paranoid that they want to deny any possibility of making things more equitable.

The last letter is the most complex for my reaction. A man says that all the persons who are illegally inside the otherwise empty bank building should be arrested for breaking and entering, conspiracy, and burglary. He says if convicted, they should lose their 'right to vote.' Why he put 'right to vote' in quotation marks is beyond me, but it makes him look like a jerk. Which he probably is.

He is right that the people who broke into the building should be responsible for cleaning up any damage they did. In this case, a empty building is not necessarily a public space, in the sense that a park is public. The question of the inherent right to private property is far too complex for me to argue over, so I won't do so, but I would say that the letter writer is overreacting. The building is empty; what is the property owner doing with the building that makes it so much more valuable empty than it would be as a symbol of political expression? Another question would be if this was a bank branch for one of the institutions that received a bailout by taxpayer money. Bailouts mean that the taxpayers have a stake in the institution until the taxpayer money is repaid in full. Furthermore, losing the right to vote over utilizing the right to free speech and freedom of expression seems overly harsh. A visceral reaction, rather than an objective reaction.

To be fair to all these letter writers, they did not hide behind the anonymity of the Internet. Internet postings can be unbelievably venomous, such as those of the brave, good people who posted comments about wanting Barney Frank to die of AIDS; and that was on a message board at SI.com, which should be about sports and fun and games. That was almost enough to make me give up liking sports, just because sports would be guilty of association with some pretty awful people.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

From The Papers: Further Amateurish Reactions To The World

Canada: The New United States, And Not In A Good Way

A climate meeting opened in South Africa on Monday, in the face of the upcoming expiration of the environmental commitments from the Kyoto Protocol. Against this backdrop, it is reported that Canada will announce a formal withdrawal from the accord next month. Really, Canada? What happened? I used to look up to you, both literally and figuratively. Oh, that's right, Harper happened. Trust me, Canada, being an international douchebag might look like fun from where you're standing, but it's not all it's cracked up to be.


College Campus Revolutions

UC Santa Cruz students and faculty staged a protest of the pepper-spraying of UC Davis students and proposed tuition fee hikes. Where to begin with this?

1) UC Davis needs to out and out fire the police officers responsible, but the question is, should it be done publicly, or should they be allowed to slip away into the night? A public shaming might trigger unfortunate responses, but would anything less than a public revelation satisfy the outrage over this particular episode? Either way, this incident must follow the officers should they attempt to apply for new jobs in law enforcement. I'm usually one to allow for extenuating circumstances and second chances, but there are no extenuating circumstances in this case, and therefore, no second chances.
2) As for the tuition hikes, yes, education is getting extremely unaffordable, and that's damaging to our society in so many ways, both in the moment and in the future. A photo of the Santa Cruz protest showed a chalked message that "Education Is A Right, Not A Privilege." Education should certainly not be only for the privileged few, but the question of whether it is a right is a little trickier. Much as one's civil liberties under the Bill of Rights, such as freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, are always limited by the rights of others to not be harmed and not have their rights infringed upon, the right to education is heavily contingent on the availability of resources. The universal ideal would be free education for all, but there is no such thing as a free lunch. Resources are needed. To use a physics metaphor, there must be potential energy in order to create kinetic energy, and life tends towards entropy.

This doesn't mean we shouldn't fight for resources, but going after the UC Regents may not be the proper approach. The regents certainly deserve criticism, and it is all well and good to make them sign a pledge that they would fight to raise taxes on the wealthy, close corporate loopholes and and end Prop. 13, but that's no more than a symbolic action. This is certainly a strong message and a coherent plan of action, but it should be targeted at Sacramento.

It is also an issue of national significance. Our priorities are wrong:instead of corporate bailouts, the money should be reinvested in education. Let the free market determine what corporations succeed; corporations that fail should dissolve and try again with a new model. Meanwhile, if we invested in education, we would be spurring the growth and development of a new generation of innovators and entrepreneurs, creating actual 'job creators' and qualifying people to fill those jobs.

What? Another Herman Cain Allegation? I'm Shocked. Shocked.

The AP describes 'an explosive allegation' in which a Georgia woman said she and Herman Cain had a thirteen year affair. Really, at this point, I think it would be more explosive news if someone came forward and said they had NOT had an affair with or been harassed by Herman Cain.

Cain denied it, but a statement from his lawyer did not repeat a denial, but instead basically said that the public and the media had no business snooping into the details of consensual conduct between adults. In general, that's true, but when you are running for president, you are no longer quite the same private individual, and your judgment must be called in to question. Whether or not he had an affair is not really a major issue except between Cain and his wife, but harassment allegations are an entirely different ballgame. Especially when you imply that God told you to run for the Presidency.

On a purely political level, does one's past mean that one can't be an effective leader? I would say no. Look at Bill Clinton. But it is important for us to be able to respect our leaders.

So yes, it is theoretically possible that Herman Cain would be a good president. But no, he wouldn't be. He's just crazy, and kind of slimy.

How The World Has Turned

A gay softball organization has had to pay an undisclosed sum of money to three players who were disqualified from the 2008 Gay Softball World Series because they were perceived to be too heterosexual, as they were bisexual.

First of all, I had no idea there was such a thing as a Gay Softball World Series. I think that is spectacular.

Second of all, I don't know why, but this strikes me as really very funny.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Sunday, April 26, 2009

A Paper In Crisis

Last Saturday, we were riding the 14-Mission toward the waterfront and the Giants ballpark, and we passed the white edifice that houses the Chronicle, to which I am currently still subscribed, if more tenuously so than I used to be.

It was fitting, I thought, that a long crack runs down the face of the building, right through the middle of the fancy lettering identifying the tenants.

At least the Chronicle doesn't have as blatant a conservative leaning and as poor an editorial staff as the Press Democrat of Santa Rosa. I bought a copy of that paper on my last trip up the coast, and it was awful. Some major typos, and an icky religious/conservative slant.

So I have not got around to canceling the Chronicle yet, but please, Chronicle, fire the hell out of Willie Brown. I glanced at his column briefly this morning to see if there was any improvement, and what I saw in his response to Gavin Newsom's gubernatorial candidacy was the following: "The current knock on our mayor is that he's not at home enough. Let me just say that home cookin' in my opinion has always been overrated."

That's not a relevant answer to the criticism of Newsom's absence from key budget meetings and other points of contention. It means nothing, all style, no substance. He's just trying to be clever, and it is really old. Don't name Third Street after him; find some cul de sac or dead end street.

Am I partly jealous that he gets to write his self-indulgences in a newspaper and I don't? Sure, but that doesn't mean he has anything useful to say.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Chronicles of a Paper Stack

For the last year or more, my weekend mornings can be summarized as follows: coffee, brewed or bought; pastries, scones, bagels, or cinnamon rolls; quiet music; and the San Francisco Chronicle.

Local newspapers, the print version, are in many ways a relic of a more patient, possibly less environmentally-friendly world, depending on one's perspective on the amount of energy required for the Internet. I'm not sure what the comparative carbon-footprints are. Nevertheless, there is something satisfying about getting all the way through an actual paper. Especially when you have to consider the value you are getting from your subscription.

When I first subscribed, I had a deal as good as drinking fine scotch in a wooded cabin on a rainy night, about $20 for 13 weeks of Wednesday through Sunday service. 13 weeks ago, the price went up to $40. I was fine with that, I could definitely afford it, and I felt good about paying to support a local daily newspaper, even though I could read the paper every day at work, and even though on many weekends, I have not been home and have been buying extra copies.

Yesterday, I got the bill for the next 13 months--which had already been charged to my credit card; you get the bill after the fact--and found the rate is now $80.

This is where I find myself wrestling with a conundrum.

The newspaper is the local daily newspaper. It is also run by a corporation. I'm not naturally inclined to trust corporations to have more than a fiduciary investment in a community, but I want to thwart the trend of newspapers dying across the country.

The corporation, while publicly fretting about having to shut down all together, has forced major concessions on the part of the union employees--union-busting, anyone? On the one hand, I would like to keep those workers employed and the newspaper in existence. On the other hand, should I support a corporation under the current paradigm of commercial journalism?

Of late, the Chronicle has made many, presumably costly, changes. These changes range from the substantive (new comics, a new round-up of headlines from newspapers around the world) to the cosmetic (the sports section being printed on green paper once again on Sundays, and an expensive new printing process to improve the visual quality) to the supposedly-substantive-but-merely-cosmetic (a new solipsistic column by a former mayor who clearly doesn't lack for self-enthusiasm). Are these changes increasing the value I get for my money? Is this the right question I should even be asking when it comes to a source of news? Is that part of the problem in and of itself? A newspaper is a profit-driven endeavor.

When you factor in the extra charge built into subscriptions to cover delivery costs, subscribing costs me more than would buying the papers daily, Wednesday-Sunday, which is a bit irritating when you consider that a subscription gives a paper a guaranteed income, upfront. Still, I can probably afford this. The question is, do I want to? When I have access to the daily paper at work, and could just buy the paper on the weekend for my ritual, is subscribing to the paper at this price worth it?

I'm not sure yet.

Labels: , , ,